I acquired into an argument with my uncle about this. My aunt asked “Who believed that Buffalo to be the capital of brand-new York?” and also my cousin responded “me and also Chris.” my uncle stated this to be incorrect, since you wouldn’t say “Me assumed Buffalo to be the capital,” but rather “I assumed Buffalo was the capital.” i understand exactly how this works, but he never said “...thought Buffalo to be the capital.” all he stated was “me and also Chris.” Does the make sense? am I appropriate or wrong?


My aunt inquiry “Who assumed that Buffalo was the resources of new York?” and my cousin responded me and Chris.” my uncle stated this was incorrect, since you i will not ~ say “Me thought Buffalo was the capital,” yet rather “I assumed Buffalo to be the capital.”


You are watching: Him and i or him and me

TLDR: What her cousin responded with is a herbal English response. That is grammatical for today's conventional English.


There are assorted grammatical methods of looking at this issue. One reasonable way is to think about that the expression "Me and also Chris" is what continues to be after a normal conversational deletion that the top "It was" native the clause "It to be me and Chris", which in its turn is the truncated 'it'-cleft because that the full 'it'-cleft "It was me and also Chris who thought that Buffalo to be the funding of brand-new York."

Also, native English speakers will generally use the accusation "me" once the 1st person personal pronoun is associated in a coordination situated after the verb, and will frequently use that "me" as the very first coordinate, as watched in the OP's "It was me and Chris".

And so, consider:

"It was me and also Chris who believed that Buffalo to be the funding of new York."

"It was me and Chris."

"Me and also Chris."

And variant #3 ("Me and also Chris") is what the OP's cousin responded with.

Also, as soon as a fragment (e.g. "Me and Chris") is talked where it involves a personal pronoun, the pronoun is commonly in accusative instance (e.g. "Me"), especially when uncoordinated. Yet the OP's example involves a coordination -- it so happens that also for pieces that consist completely of a coordination entailing a an individual pronoun as a coordinate, the pronoun will frequently be in accusative case.

See more: How Many Cups Of Chicken In A Pound ? How Many Chicken Breasts In A Pound

Consider these feasible responses to the concern of "Who desires ice cream?":



"Me and also Chris."

"Chris and also me."

"I and also Chris."

"Chris and also I."

In general, when personal pronouns comprise the entirety fragment or much of that (as in a coordination), those an individual pronouns are commonly in accusative case (e.g. "me"), and also this kind of intake is so usual that the accusative situation could be considered to it is in the default or unmarked case for an individual pronouns.