Thanksgiving is quick approaching and you’ve gained all her meals assumed out, the just thing absent is the pie. How soon have the right to you do it, and also how long deserve to it continue to be in the refrigerator ?

Does pumpkin pie should be refrigerated ? You’ve seem them ~ above shelves in supermarkets and they didn’t it seems ~ cold. And if you decide to buy a pre-made one, perform you must refrigerate that as well ? how long is it great for ?

No one ever before said Thanksgiving or any big holiday is basic to cook for. Especially if you’ve got expanded family comes over, or simply a huge immediate family. Several mouths mean numerous food, and also that means carefully to plan what and also when come cook.

You are watching: How long is pumpkin pie good for in the fridge

Hopefully we’ll have the ability to ease her mind, and also tell you every little thing you should know around pumpkin pie front of time. So let’s begin with whether it needs to stay in the fridge or not.


Table the Contents

Why pumpkin pie needs to cool down

Does pumpkin pie should be refrigerated ?

Yes, pumpkin pie demands to it is in refrigerated, otherwise it deserve to go bad. ~ all, the pie pour it until it is full is a type of custard made v eggs, milk, sugar, spices, and pumpkin puree.

We introduce you allow the pie cool in ~ room temperature for a couple of hours after acquisition it the end of the oven. Then, girlfriend should ar plastic wrap on the optimal to keep it from soaking up smells native the fridge. Put it in the fridge, and also it should be an excellent for 3-4 days.

Of course, if you’re baking the pie on Thanksgiving job you have the right to serve it as quickly as it’s cooled down. If you’re very an excellent at multitasking then you deserve to probably pull the off. If not, climate you’re more than likely going to bake the pie the day before and keep that chilled until needed.

Read also: Pumpkin Pie pour it until it is full VS Pumpkin Puree 

Why space store purchase pumpkin pies no refrigerated ?

The key reason keep bought pies (of any kind) are not refrigerated is due to the fact that they save on computer preservatives the make castle shelf-stable. This means that you deserve to leave them on the respond to overnight, and also they will certainly still be an excellent for a few days. Or at the very least until the best-by date printed on the label.

Homemade pies room not shelf-stable, they can’t be. They have dairy and also eggs, i m sorry spoil very quickly. Even if save bought pies room safe to leave on the counter, we recommend you put them in the fridge.

This will store them for sure to eat no issue what, and you can include a few more days to the best-by date.

How long deserve to pumpkin pie sit out ?

Homemade pumpkin pie shouldn’t sit the end for much more than 12 hours. Four to six hours is the encourage time to let a new pie cool off and reach room temperature.

The much more you leaving it, the an ext likely you room to get a spoiled pie. Store-bought pie isn’t together sensitive and can be left out for a few days.

Why pumpkin pie needs to cool down

Let’s talk around pumpkin pie and also why it needs to cool down. In reality this applies to any type of custard pie, choose a lemon curd pie or a vanilla tart.

The whole allude of the pie is to acquire the custard come set, and thus become edible. You cannot bake the custard till it’s set in the oven, since residual heat in the pie will chef it also further. Not just that, but a cracked custard is generally the result of one overbaked pie.

This is why the pie demands to be slightly jiggly in the center when you take it out of the oven. In the adhering to hour or so the residual heat will cook the custard and also you’ll it is in left v a smooth, perfectly small pie.

The best means to make certain your pie comes the end perfect is to revolve off the oven once the center is quiet a little bit jiggly. Jiggly, not wet and sloshing ! Then, leave the range door ajar through the pie inside. This does 2 things.

First, the residual warm from the oven will cook the pie further.

Second, you’re no exposing warm pie to cold air right away. So you have less the a opportunity of gaining a cracked custard.

Can friend eat pumpkin pie appropriate out of the oven ?

If you to be to slice right into a pumpkin pie as soon as it’s tho hot, you’d get a mess. The center would merely melt or fall apart, and also you’d gain a nice unsightly pie.

Not only that, however the custard won’t be totally cooked, or set. You likewise risk cracked or deflating the custard an ext than necessary.

In short please it is in patient and also wait for the pie to cool down. If you choose you pie warm, only let that cool for about 2 hours.

Is pumpkin pie served warmth or cold ?

That is totally up to you. Most folks end up eat the pie cold, since it’s refrigerated, because it’s made the work before. Even as soon as it’s made the day-of, the still demands to cool down and most folks favor making that in the morning, for this reason it has actually plenty of time come cool.

In a way, it’s much better to eat pumpkin pie cold, due to the fact that in basic sweet foods items taste much better cold. There’s also the fact that the spices will develop an ext in the hrs after the pie is baked. The same method a curry is much better the following day, than instantly after cooking.

However if you want to sere your pie warm, you still need to let it cool after ~ removing from the oven. Just let the cool for around 2 hours, and then it will certainly still it is in warm.

If her pie has already cooled turn off completely, you deserve to gently microwave it on low (not medium, not high) for a few minutes. If girlfriend use as well high a setup you’ll burn the outside and the center will be lukewarm at best.

How long is pumpkin pie great for ?

In the fridge pumpkin pie can last up to 4 work after baking. The being said, us recommend you eat the pie within 2 days, since the flavors will walk off easily afterwards.

If her pie is home-made and also on the counter, you shouldn’t keep it out for much more than 12 hours. Friend won’t need to throw it out, however you hazard it begging a monster flavor. It’s finest to refrigerate it after it’s cooled, so after around 4-6 hours.

And in the case of store bought pie, you can keep it because that as long as the best-by day says. If you placed it in the fridge, you deserve to push a few days past the published date.

Finally, if you’re to plan on freezing the pie, it need to only be maintained for around a month, two maybe. You might be disappointed when you take it the end though. The custard won’t be every that exceptional in texture, however the flavor need to be the same.

How have the right to you call if pumpkin pie is poor ?

The an initial way come tell your pumpkin pie’s gone poor is to odor it. In fact, you could even odor it beforehand. There’s pumpkin, milk, and eggs in there. All 3 of those smell terrible when they walk bad.

Another thing to look for is excessive moisture on the top of the custard. If it’s starting to gain pools of water (not the ones from plastic wrap on top) and also it’s separating, it’s ideal to throw it out.

Obviously, if you see tiny specks that mold (white or blue), there’s no point in keeping it.

And finally, if you understand you baked the pie Monday morning and you’re opening the fridge Friday evening, don’t even think around the pie. It’s already lost the flavor and also most most likely the texture together well.

Can you do pumpkin pie the day prior to Thanksgiving ?

Yes, you can make pumpkin pie the day prior to Thanksgiving, also two days prior to if you’re a very busy cook. Pumpkin pie will store for as lengthy as 4 days in the fridge, yet we recommend eat it within 2 days of baking.

You have the right to mask any kind of imperfections with some whipped cream, and/or sprinkle part extra cinnamon ~ above top.

See more: How Many Tomatillos In A Pound, Tomatillos Cooking Growing And Eating : Article

If you’ve got any kind of other food curiosities be sure to examine the related short articles below, we’re always adding an ext food facts to make her life that lot easier.